Tinkster, I ate the Bluegill that Steve gave me (yum). But they were fillets- I didn't kill, clean, etc myself. I think if they've been in your freezer for years, they probably aren't any good to eat.
Frogman3, I really want some of those Pumpkinseeds, they're adorable. We've got them here, I just need to get out there and catch some. Pumpkinseeds and Bluegills can mate and produce hybrids that are difficult to identify.
Ruthie, my little stalker is always at the ready.
How big of a goldfish do they eat? I'm wondering what the cut-off is, cuz most of my goldies are large, but I have a few babies from last summer that are only about an inch or two long. The Bluegill can eat all the eggs/babies she wants, but I do like my bigger ones.